Are you sure you want to sign out?
User Name  Password
Survivor - The CBS Television Series
Keep us ad-free. Please click to donate.
Title: American Idol has a new 4th judge
Hop to: 
Views:33     
<<Previous ThreadNext Thread>>
Page 1 / 1    
AuthorComment
LindaJean
 Author    



Posts: 364
From: USA
Registered: 11/13/2008

(Date Posted:09/10/2009 14:09 PM)



(Message edited by CindiLou On 09/10/2009 14:15 PM)
CindiLou
1# 



Status:I still despise Russell
Posts:364
From: USA
Registered:02/18/2009

RE:American Idle has a new 4th judge
(Date Posted:09/10/2009 14:14 PM)

I heard that this morning and found it hard to believe also. Doesn't Ellen have enough to do with her daily talk show and her Covergirl contract? How will she fit in American Idol also? And does Ellen have any singing background? I know she can dance quite well but singing?
LindaJean
2# 



Posts:364
From: USA
Registered:11/13/2008

Re:American Idol has a new 4th judge
(Date Posted:09/10/2009 14:35 PM)

As a guest judge for one week I could see, but not a 4th judge to replace Paula.  Ellen was a guest judge on SYTYCD one week.  She loves to dance and she was funny and that was ok for a week. She really is not qualified to be a judge on AI
OregonJonsey
3# 



Status:Of course the rains cometh
Posts:675
From: USA
Registered:10/28/2008

RE:American Idol has a new 4th judge
(Date Posted:09/11/2009 06:49 AM)

I'm sure she is there for comedy relief and also ratings.  She has a huge fan base.
They have the three other judges to "tell them" what they're doing right or wrong so
I'm going to give the benefit of the doubt to Ellen for now.  But being a female, I
reserve the right to change my mind.
tanyaw
4# 



Status: Russell = Idol magnet
Posts:518
From: USA
Registered:10/31/2008

RE:American Idol has a new 4th judge
(Date Posted:09/11/2009 08:18 AM)

I was surprised to see that Ellen was chosen, seems like an odd choice to me.  She has a wonderful sense of humor, that I will enjoy.



(Message edited by tanyaw On 09/11/2009 08:19 AM)

--------------------------------------------------------------
pcwaxgirl
5# 



Status:Be careful, Shambo.
Posts:292
From: USA
Registered:11/12/2008

Re:American Idol has a new 4th judge
(Date Posted:09/14/2009 08:17 AM)

I'm not an Ellen fan (probably the only one left in America!).  I thought her humor on SYTYCD was silly.  I'm not so sure she's the right choice for the position.  Doesn't AI have good ratings already?  I really don't think they need Ellen to boost them.

On the other hand I'm hoping Kara has been practicing this summer!
OregonJonsey
6# 



Status:Of course the rains cometh
Posts:675
From: USA
Registered:10/28/2008

RE:American Idol has a new 4th judge
(Date Posted:09/14/2009 08:43 AM)

AI continues to slip in ratings every year...so they say anyway.
<<Previous ThreadNext Thread>>
Page 1 / 1    


Copyright © 2000-2009 Aimoo Free Forum All rights reserved.